Europe must ‘leverage the complementarities’ between industrial and competition policy, Coeuré says

Europe must ‘leverage the complementarities’ between industrial and competition policy, Coeuré says

10 September 2024
By Natalie McNelis

The “defining challenge” for the next European Commission will be to build a system that marries competition and industrial policy and “leverages their complementarities,” President Benoît Coeuré of France's Autorité de la Concurrence told MLex in an exclusive interview.

“We want to build a system that works for European firms and for European consumers, and that means we have to build a new system where competition enforcement and industrial policy will be complements, rather than substitutes.”

Coeuré, who has been head of the French competition watchdog since January 2022, said the political discourse has changed entirely during that time — in reaction to the Covid 19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, the energy crisis and an increasing risk of fragmentation in the global trading system.

“Europe has to defend its sovereignty and design a long-term strategy for its industry, its resources and its resilience. The big question for us competition enforcers is how does that change, if at all, the way we enforce competition policy?” Coeuré said.

His reflections come at a time of churn for the EU, with the impending change of leadership at its institutions. Mario Draghi, the former head of the European Central Bank tasked with drawing up recommendations for the next mandate, has suggested a policy overhaul to make the EU more competitive.

“At the political level, I would really encourage the policymakers, the commission and [European] Parliament, to connect the dots and to have a vision that reconciles industrial policy and competition,” he said.

“It’s not a competition. We’ve got to leverage all the positive complementarities between them.”

“There has been a bit of a defensive tone in the antitrust community, that these discussions are not for us, and we have to be focused on our narrow mandate — antitrust enforcement — and 'industrial policy' or 'sovereignty' or 'resilience' — buzz words in the political discussion — are at best irrelevant and maybe even a nuisance for us.”

“That’s wrong. We are not living in a vacuum and we have got to be mindful of our political environment,” he said.

Competition policy is only one instrument of European policy, but it has a role to play, Coeuré said.

“You can't expect European companies to be competitive on the global stage if they’re not on the local stage. It is not by stifling competition that you are going to have European champions,” he said.

He also highlighted the role of competition policy in promoting innovation.

“Innovation flourishes on competition,” and if Europe wants to emulate the creative, innovative environments of other countries like the United States, it has to ensure markets remain contestable, he said.

Coeuré said that his starting point as a competition regulator is not that there has been too much competition enforcement, but rather too little industrial policy.

"The best protection for competition policy is to have an industrial policy that works."

“If you want to ‘scale up’ the European industry, we've also got to ‘scale up’ industrial policy — and we need to find the right resources for doing it.”

“It has to be European resources, and not an industrial policy based on national resources — because that is a source of fragmentation for the single market, a source of competition between member states. And it's a drain on fiscal resources, which are today very scarce.”

“Plus, it gives an edge to those countries which have a lower debt level and creates unfair competition in the system,” he said.

“If we have an industrial policy that is leveled up, sized up, and that works, there will be less pressure on competition policy,” Coeuré said.

For the latest developments on all things antitrust, activate your instant trial of MLex today.

bridge near body of water